Posted by
PLS on Thursday, April 09, 2009 7:33:35 PM
I hear on the radio and TV that it is important to give and volunteer and I agree with those sentiments. I don’t agree with this concept that the way to give to charity or the poor is through the government. Some how people have come to equate paying taxes to help the poor is the same as actually giving to help the poor. It is not the same.
1. If you give yourself you direct the flow of the money and to what organizations it goes to it can be local or global it is up to you. If the government give it goes to the place that is going to get the most votes or what the government decides is pressing
2. If you give it comes from your heart. The government takes your money by the law and the threat of force if you don’t pay.
3. If you give you have the discretion on how much to give and you can stop giving if the organization or person is not responsible. The government always requires being paid and you can not stop if you think the government is not being responsible.
4. Private charities can separate from the deserving poor and the undeserving poor i.e. those that want to improve and change there ways and those that do not. The government because of how it is founded can not do that.
Based on these four reasons it is more obvious why when one is giving or volunteering it is better to do it yourself and not depend on the government. America is already renown on our private giving that usually exceeds the giving of entire nations that engage in foreign AID. I think Americans should seek to grow private giving and reduce government giving because we are not able to hold them to the same standards or demands drastic reforms like givers can do with private organization because of the competition private not for profits face in competing for our dollars.